Hi Kids, I like tanks. Not sure why. I also like airplanes, locomotives, cars, etc. And books. I really like books far too much to be healthy. If I ever move there are going to be double hernias all around! I've never been in the army and never had to keep a tank operational. I might not be as appreciative if I had. I have driven some armoured vehicles while on vaca in the UK, including the Chieftain. For a couple years I was saving up for an armoured car or a Chieftain (IIRC US$17,000!!!) but the government made it illegal to import them. I think that law might have been changed again, but buying a motorcycle has taught me the zen of not owning everything I see.
A lot of these are coffee table books with huge pictures, but you gotta start somewhere. I've had the bug bad enough that I've been to the War and Peace Show (Beltring) a couple times. I even helped a guy work on his ex-Yugoslav M36 while there. (I handed him a tool he asked for, my 20 seconds of hands on experience.) I've also been to Aberdeen, Bovington, Duxford, The Littlefield Collection, the Patton Museum, and some other museums out in California. Still need to make it to Russia!
This is the first book I ever had about tanks. In fact, my favorite tank has always been the Chieftain, possibly because there's a two page spread of one with the turret rotated sideways and the gun sticking out a country mile. Just looks awesome! Now that I think about it, a lot of these books have Chieftains on the cover. Maybe because they were printed in the UK or the commonwealth.
Got this one as a birthday present. It's amazing what Mom's will do to keep the kids happy! It goes for about US$250+ on the internet now. WOW!
Still don't understand half of this one.
Picked up this one back in the mid-1990's. It's the only one I have that describes all the weird one-off and pre-production weirdness (US T-6, T-20, VK3002MAN, etc etc) we now see on World of Tanks the computer game.
If there's one guy who can make a book about tanks hilarious, its Ian Hogg. I'd recommend everything he's written.
George Forty got a bunch of stuff out too. Always worth picking up!
A chronicle of my gaming adventures and misadventures with a little bit of everything occasionally tossed in. It covers Flames of War, Warhammer 40k and Fantasy battle, Disposable Heroes, Sky galleons of Mars, Chasepot and Needle Gun, The Sword and the Flame, Warhammer Ancients and many others.
Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts
Saturday, May 16, 2015
Wednesday, July 16, 2014
Two Books for those who think Germany won the war
Hi Kids, "Panther vs. Sherman" Required Reading!!!!
It's come to my attention that many, many, wargamers are under the impression that Germany could not have lost World War Two. Far too many in fact. This bizarre belief might be (in my humble opinion) due to the nifty stuff Germany built. Everything from the Panther and Tiger tanks, Mauser rifles, MG34's & 42's, Bf109's and FW190's, battleships Bismark and Tirpitz; it all seems to be just so high tech and nifty. With stuff that nifty how can you lose? The only advantage the Allies possess seems to be reliability and vast numbers. Wargames tend to reinforce this notion; after all, how many tactical games feature possible break downs? The only one I can think of is Squad Leader. How many of us have taken our Allied tanks to battle only to have them all blown apart (one shot one kill) by the Tiger boys*? I dream of the scenario where the German player pays the points for 4 Tigers and only gets one due to reliability, while the USA player gets 9 out of 10 Shermans. I once was dragooned into playing an Eastern Front mini game where the Russians were absolutely helpless while the Germans destroyed everything this side of the horizon without breaking a sweat. When I asked how the British and US tanks did in this game I was told that the rule author left them out cause they were so bad it won't be any fun to play. (Doesn't that mean the rules are rather inaccurate?) But on to the book review:
This first book, "Panther vs. Sherman" by none other than Steve Zaloga, points out that the early Panthers at Kursk had teething problems. ("Everybody knows that" I hear you mutter.) The Panther serviceability rate at that battle was 17%! That's one out of six!!! By year end it had risen to 33%!!! This book should be required reading for all the Tiger Boys out there. I showed this book to a Tiger Boy and he said, "It must have been written by some Brit or American who doesn't know crap about tanks." He's never heard of Steve Zaloga? Seriously? Possibly the most prolific author regarding tanks for the past 25 years? Zaloga examines the specific details of both tanks in the specific time period in a very engaging way; including units, intended purpose, and crew quality. At any rate everyone who plays WW2 ground combat needs to read this book. It's an Osprey so its easy to find and cheap to buy. Do yourself a favor and pick it up soon. I got a real kick out of it, and picked up some real useful knowledge. Nah, I won't tell ya how it ends.
Well, I hate to be the one to break it to ya, ( Brace Yourselves!!) but Germany lost World War Two.
I picked up this second book as a lark. Although it includes some info about prior wars (Napoleonic, Franco-Prussian, WW1), this book is mostly about the WW2 German High Command; the various generals and field marshals and how they interacted with Hitler. It points out some mistakes made, even early in WW2. Macksey evaluates them and comes to some startling conclusions. I was hoping it would have more information about production. And I wish he had gone into more detail regarding the political maneuvering amongst the commanders. I can tell Macksey was done a lot of research, including interviews with some of the principle characters, but it just doesn't make it into the volume. I got the impression it could have been 100+ pages longer. It is more of a brief overview of the subject rather than an end-all be-all explosion of the myth.
*Tiger Boy is a derogatory term used to describe a player who always has Tigers and Panthers in his forces. Always. Mid War FOW is a great example. There were what, a dozen or so Tigers in North Africa at the very end of the conflict, so I have to face them 99% of the time? Of the 1800 examples of Tiger and King Tiger actually built, I have faced each one about 100 times.
It's come to my attention that many, many, wargamers are under the impression that Germany could not have lost World War Two. Far too many in fact. This bizarre belief might be (in my humble opinion) due to the nifty stuff Germany built. Everything from the Panther and Tiger tanks, Mauser rifles, MG34's & 42's, Bf109's and FW190's, battleships Bismark and Tirpitz; it all seems to be just so high tech and nifty. With stuff that nifty how can you lose? The only advantage the Allies possess seems to be reliability and vast numbers. Wargames tend to reinforce this notion; after all, how many tactical games feature possible break downs? The only one I can think of is Squad Leader. How many of us have taken our Allied tanks to battle only to have them all blown apart (one shot one kill) by the Tiger boys*? I dream of the scenario where the German player pays the points for 4 Tigers and only gets one due to reliability, while the USA player gets 9 out of 10 Shermans. I once was dragooned into playing an Eastern Front mini game where the Russians were absolutely helpless while the Germans destroyed everything this side of the horizon without breaking a sweat. When I asked how the British and US tanks did in this game I was told that the rule author left them out cause they were so bad it won't be any fun to play. (Doesn't that mean the rules are rather inaccurate?) But on to the book review:
This first book, "Panther vs. Sherman" by none other than Steve Zaloga, points out that the early Panthers at Kursk had teething problems. ("Everybody knows that" I hear you mutter.) The Panther serviceability rate at that battle was 17%! That's one out of six!!! By year end it had risen to 33%!!! This book should be required reading for all the Tiger Boys out there. I showed this book to a Tiger Boy and he said, "It must have been written by some Brit or American who doesn't know crap about tanks." He's never heard of Steve Zaloga? Seriously? Possibly the most prolific author regarding tanks for the past 25 years? Zaloga examines the specific details of both tanks in the specific time period in a very engaging way; including units, intended purpose, and crew quality. At any rate everyone who plays WW2 ground combat needs to read this book. It's an Osprey so its easy to find and cheap to buy. Do yourself a favor and pick it up soon. I got a real kick out of it, and picked up some real useful knowledge. Nah, I won't tell ya how it ends.
Well, I hate to be the one to break it to ya, ( Brace Yourselves!!) but Germany lost World War Two.
I picked up this second book as a lark. Although it includes some info about prior wars (Napoleonic, Franco-Prussian, WW1), this book is mostly about the WW2 German High Command; the various generals and field marshals and how they interacted with Hitler. It points out some mistakes made, even early in WW2. Macksey evaluates them and comes to some startling conclusions. I was hoping it would have more information about production. And I wish he had gone into more detail regarding the political maneuvering amongst the commanders. I can tell Macksey was done a lot of research, including interviews with some of the principle characters, but it just doesn't make it into the volume. I got the impression it could have been 100+ pages longer. It is more of a brief overview of the subject rather than an end-all be-all explosion of the myth.
*Tiger Boy is a derogatory term used to describe a player who always has Tigers and Panthers in his forces. Always. Mid War FOW is a great example. There were what, a dozen or so Tigers in North Africa at the very end of the conflict, so I have to face them 99% of the time? Of the 1800 examples of Tiger and King Tiger actually built, I have faced each one about 100 times.
Monday, March 17, 2014
"Bridge of Birds" by Barry Hughart Book Review
Hi Kids, This one is a radical departure from what I usually read, in fact you could say I went completely off the reservation. But every once and awhile I take a break from history and check out what the cool kids are doing. And in this case I'm glad I did. "Bridge of Birds" is an absolute masterpiece. It is subtitled "A Novel of Ancient China That Never Was." It's basically a fairy tale of epic proportions as the two main characters; Number 10 Ox and Li Kao (who has a slight character flaw) go on a series of adventures to save the children from a mysterious illness. They encounter all sorts of weirdness and bizarre characters to find the Great Root of Power, the only cure for the kids. My personal fav is when Ox has to perform the Sword Dance against a ghost with a broken heart. "It is said that the challenge of the Sword Dance is stronger than death itself. I'd do it myself if I could be ninety again, but it looks as though you can have the honor of chopping off your arms and legs," says Li Kao. Hundreds if not thousands of people are killed or maimed each year during the Sword Dance! Barry has a serious gift with words, and I'm going to have to check and see if he's ever written anything else. My used copy was only US$2.00, so get thee to a bookstore post haste!
Sunday, November 3, 2013
The Banana Wars by Ivan Musicant book review
Hi Kids, Ordinarily this time period is not my cup o' tea, but with the massive boom in Pulp era gaming over the last few years I figured I'd do a wee bit o' research and find out what was going on down south over the last 100 years. And buddy, I'm glad I did! This 420 page tome was a great choice! All the info the hard working gamer needs is here, even the freakin' bibliography is 10 pages long! Each country has it's own chapter or two; Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, Panama. Chesty Puller would be proud, and Smedley Butler (one of the few guys to be awarded TWO Congressional Medals of Honor! (AND lived through it!)) turns up on more than one occasion. One of my favorite anecdotes was how the Marines were roused from sleep by Butler yelling, "Who wants a fight?" They then charged out to repel an attack, half dressed but fully armed. I'm tellin' ya, ya just can't make this stuff up. Jungle patrols, hidden forts, trains burned, customs houses raided, gunboat diplomacy, every kind of scenario you need. There's even a guy named Dr. Bobo. Musicant's style is easily read and very entertaining, if you have any interest in this time period or chunk of the planet I highly recommend this book. He also has written a few books about warships, I might have to pick them up too!
Wednesday, October 23, 2013
The Last Valley by Martin Windrow book review
Hi Kids, Some of you might know that one of my favorite units of all time is the French Foreign Legion, and I tend to buy most of the books in English regarding them. (Well, if I can afford them!) Martin Windrow has written quite a few of those books, and naturally the battle of Dien Bien Phu crops up every once and awhile. "The Last Valley" is about that battle, and it is an absolute masterpiece! It has replaced Jules Roy's "The Battle of DienBienPhu" as my favorite, and that's saying a lot. If I had to have just one book about the French in Indochina, this would be the one. Even if you have no particular interest in the battle, some of the descriptions of the military action are worth reading. It's been out in paperback for awhile now, so you kids should rush right out and pick one up! I bet www.abebooks.com has 'em cheap! If John Keegan digs it, its got to be good!
Labels:
Book Review,
Chuckaroobob,
French,
French Foreign Legion,
Moderns,
Vietnam
Thursday, October 10, 2013
"Once a Pilgrim" by Will Scully book
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)